Them Days and its staff have been honoured with several awards throughout its five-decade history:
- 1981: Doris Saunders, Editor, Regional History Prize from the Canadian Historical Association
- 1984: Heritage of Newfoundland and Labrador Award from the Newfoundland and Labrador Arts Council
- 1986: Doris Saunders, Editor, Member of the Order of Canada
- 1994: Doris Saunders, Northern Telecom Arts Achievement Award, Newfoundland and Labrador Arts Council
- 1994: Doris Saunders, Editor, Honorary Doctorate of Letters, Memorial University
- 2009: Manning Award for the Public Presentation of Historical Places from the Historic Sites Association
- 2016: Shortlisted for the Governor General’s History Award for Excellence in Community Programming
- 2019: Heritage Award from the Newfoundland and Labrador Historical Society
- 2024: Premier’s Award for Heritage (inaugural) from the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador